Salary Comparison Calculator
How Much of a Pay Rise Do You Actually Keep?
When comparing two job offers or negotiating a salary increase in the UK, looking only at headline gross pay can be misleading. Because the UK tax system features progressive Income Tax bands, National Insurance thresholds, and aggressive benefit clawbacks, the percentage of a pay rise you actually keep in your pocket varies dramatically across different earning brackets for the 2026/27 tax year:
- Basic-Rate Band (£12,570 to £50,270): A £5,000 pay rise from £40,000 to £45,000 yields £3,600.00 extra take-home pay per year (£300.00 per month). You retain exactly 72.0% of the increase, facing a combined marginal deduction rate of 28% (20% basic-rate Income Tax + 8% Class 1 National Insurance).
- Higher-Rate Band (£50,270 to £100,000): Across this band, Income Tax rises to 40% while employee National Insurance drops to 2%, creating a combined marginal deduction rate of 42% (or 51% if you repay a Plan 2 student loan). You keep 58% of pay increases in this bracket.
- The £100,000 to £125,140 Taper Trap: On income above £100,000, HMRC reduces your £12,570 Personal Allowance by £1 for every £2 of adjusted net income. This withdrawal creates an effective 62% marginal deduction rate (40% higher-rate tax + 20% lost allowance clawback + 2% National Insurance). For example, a £15,000 rise from £95,000 to £110,000 yields only £6,700.00 in additional take-home pay — you retain just 38% of earnings between £100,000 and £110,000.
Worked Example: £40,000 vs £45,000 Job Offers (2026/27 Rates)
- Offer A (£40,000): Income Tax £5,486.00, National Insurance £2,194.40 → Take-Home: £32,319.60/yr (£2,693.30/month).
- Offer B (£45,000): Income Tax £6,486.00, National Insurance £2,594.40 → Take-Home: £35,919.60/yr (£2,993.30/month).
- Net Difference: Offer B leaves you +£3,600.00/yr (+£300.00/month) better off — you keep 72.0% of the £5,000 gross difference.
For a complete line-by-line breakdown of statutory deductions on a single salary, explore our flagship take-home pay calculator. If either employment offer includes an annual performance bonus or commission, note that bonuses are taxed under distinct payroll rules and are not modelled here — calculate the exact bonus retention using our bonus tax calculator.
Does Salary Sacrifice Change Which Offer Wins?
Workplace pension structures play a critical role in determining which employment offer leaves you financially better off. In the UK, pension schemes operate under two distinct arrangements: Salary Sacrifice (smart pensions) and Relief at Source:
- Salary Sacrifice: You formally agree to reduce your contractual gross salary in exchange for an equivalent employer pension contribution. Because assessable earnings are reduced before payroll calculations occur, you save both Income Tax and employee National Insurance (8% in the basic-rate band, 2% in the higher-rate band). In addition, student loan repayments decrease because repayments are assessed on post-sacrifice salary.
- Relief at Source: Contributions are deducted from your net pay after Income Tax and National Insurance have already been collected. The employee pays 80% of the total contribution from net pay, and your pension provider claims the 20% basic-rate tax relief directly from HMRC to top up your pot to 100%. However, because National Insurance is calculated on your full gross salary, you miss out on National Insurance savings.
Worked Example: £50,000 Salary with 5% Pension (£2,500 in Pot)
- Under Salary Sacrifice: Assessable gross pay becomes £47,500. Income Tax is £6,986.00 and National Insurance is £2,794.40. Your take-home pay is £37,719.60/yr (£3,143.30/month).
- Under Relief at Source: Gross pay remains £50,000. Income Tax is £7,486.00 and National Insurance is £2,994.40. The net 80% pension contribution deducted from net pay is £2,000.00. Your take-home pay is £37,519.60/yr (£3,126.63/month).
- The Advantage: Salary sacrifice leaves you £200.00/yr (£16.67/month) better off — exactly representing the 8% National Insurance saving on the £2,500 contribution (£2,500 × 8% = £200) — while your pension pot receives the full £2,500 either way.
Note that higher-rate and additional-rate taxpayers on relief-at-source schemes must claim their extra 20% or 25% tax relief through an annual HMRC Self Assessment return or by contacting HMRC directly; higher-rate top-up relief through self-assessment is not modelled in monthly payroll comparisons.
How Does Child Benefit Affect a Salary Comparison?
If you or your partner receive statutory Child Benefit, accepting a higher salary offer can trigger the High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC). For 2026/27, Child Benefit provides £27.05 per week for the eldest or only child and £17.90 per week for each additional child. For a family with two eligible children, this totals £2,337.40 per year (£44.95 per week).
Under statutory legislation, the High Income Child Benefit Charge claws back benefit payments when an individual’s adjusted net income exceeds £60,000:
- The Taper Rate: The charge equals 1% of the total Child Benefit for every £100 of income above £60,000. Between £60,000 and £80,000, the charge gradually scales until 100% of the benefit is clawed back.
- At £65,000 Income: On an income of £65,000, the excess over £60,000 is £5,000. Dividing £5,000 by £100 gives 50, meaning 50% of your Child Benefit is clawed back. For two children, the charge equals £1,168.70 per year (£97.39 per month).
- The Higher-Earner Rule: By statutory law, the HICBC is assessed exclusively on the individual with the higher adjusted net income in the household. If your partner earns more than either job offer, the charge falls entirely on your partner and does not change when you switch jobs — in that scenario, the charge represents a fixed household figure rather than a deduction from your new salary.
If your payslip reflects non-standard tax adjustments, medical benefits, or marriage allowance transfers, verify your exact tax code with our tax code calculator. If you are repaying student finance and want to estimate when your remaining balance will be cancelled by the government, check our student loan write-off checker.
Related UK Tax & Finance Calculators
Take-Home Pay Calculator
Calculate your net pay after Income Tax, National Insurance, and Student Loan deductions for 2026/27.
Calculate Salary → TaxIncome Tax Calculator
View exact tax band breakdowns for England, Wales, NI, and Scotland (all 6 devolved tiers).
Calculate Tax → PropertyStamp Duty (SDLT) Calculator
Calculate residential SDLT for standard moves, first-time buyer relief, and additional properties.
Calculate SDLT →